Mass murder in the Bay of Islands

20 November 1841

Maketū Wharetōtara, the 17-year-old son of the Ngāpuhi chief Ruhe, killed five people at Motuarohia in the Bay of Islands. In March 1842 he became the first person to be legally executed in this country.

Maketū worked on the farm of a widow, Elizabeth Roberton. His killing spree began when he attacked another farm worker, Thomas Bull, with an axe while he slept. Maketū went on to kill Roberton, her two children, and Isabella Brind, a granddaughter of the Ngāpuhi leader Rewa who lived with the Robertons.

Maketū killed his victims because he believed they had offended his mana. Bull had been verbally and physically abusive towards him, and Mrs Roberton had sworn at him. Maketū failed to explain why he had killed the two children and Isabella. In the end it was perhaps the last killing that sealed his fate.

Maketū sought refuge in his father’s village. Local settlers feared the killings were the start of something bigger and the police magistrate, Thomas Beckham, refused to act for fear of provoking Maketū’s kin. In the end Ruhe surrendered his son so as to avoid war with Rewa over the killing of his granddaughter.

Image: Maketū Wharetōtara